Commercial Lease Assignments: Balancing Tenant Flexibility and Landlord Control
Loading . . .
Loading . . .
The assignment clause in commercial leases is a critical and often contentious point of negotiation. It represents a delicate balance between a tenant's need for flexibility and a landlord's desire for control over their property.
When a tenant assigns their lease, they're essentially transferring their entire interest in the leased space to a third party for the remainder of the lease term. For tenants, this can serve as a valuable exit strategy or a means to adapt to changing business needs. Landlords, on the other hand, view assignments as a way to maintain a steady income stream and keep their properties occupied, ideally avoiding tenant defaults or bankruptcies.
Interestingly, if a lease doesn't address assignments, most jurisdictions default to allowing tenants to freely assign their interests. This legal stance favoring property alienation means that landlords typically include detailed assignment provisions in their lease agreements.
The concept of "reasonableness" often takes center stage in these provisions. Many leases state that a landlord's consent to an assignment "shall not be unreasonably withheld." However, what constitutes "reasonable" can be a matter of interpretation. Landlords often prefer to outline specific criteria they can consider when evaluating an assignment request, such as:
Without such specifics, determining what's "reasonable" could potentially lead to disputes or even litigation.
It's worth noting that courts generally frown upon landlords who deny consent solely to extract economic concessions or significantly improve their financial position beyond the original lease terms. To protect their interests in a rising market, landlords often include provisions for sharing excess rental income or retaining the right to recapture the space if an assignment is proposed.
Other common elements in assignment clauses include:
Both office and retail leases often contain detailed language outlining what constitutes reasonable grounds for withholding consent. These might include concerns about the assignee's business reputation, financial stability, or intended use of the space.
In navigating assignment provisions, both landlords and tenants should be aware of local laws and market norms. Striking the right balance between flexibility and control is key to crafting a mutually beneficial commercial lease agreement.